Plastic Contamination Prompts Nationwide Ice Cream Recall — See the Full List of Affected Products

A major ice cream recall is underway across the U.S. after Wells Enterprises—also known as Wells Dairy—voluntarily pulled 22 varieties of ice cream and frozen yogurt from circulation due to a risk of plastic contamination.

The recall, issued on April 25, affects products distributed to over 100 food service locations across the country, including restaurants, cafeterias, and institutional kitchens. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has labeled the recall as Class II, meaning the products could pose temporary or medically reversible health effects, although the chance of serious injury is low.

Why This Matters

The contamination involves hard plastic, which can be dangerous if accidentally consumed—potentially causing choking, dental damage, or internal injury.

Recalls like this are precautionary steps food companies take when products might contain foreign materials, allergens, or harmful bacteria. Though not considered an immediate health crisis, this recall was issued to prevent any risk to consumers.

What’s Affected

The recalled items are large 3-gallon tubs of ice cream and frozen yogurt, with “Best If Used By” dates between March and October 2026. They include a mix of flavors and brands, from house names to products distributed under private labels.

The largest impacted batch involves over 5,000 tubs of Vanilla Frozen Yogurt. Other affected varieties include:

• Rocky Road
• Mocha Almond Fudge
• Peanut Butter ’N Fudge
• Cotton Candy
• French Vanilla
• Madagascar Vanilla Bean
• Chocolate
• Several flavors under brands like Johnny Rockets, Gordon Choice, Glenview Farms, Sysco, and more

Scroll to the bottom for the full list of recalled UPCs and lot numbers

What Experts Are Saying

Byron D. Chaves, a food science professor at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, says contamination at this scale can happen during various stages of industrial production.

“Foreign objects like hard plastic can come from mixing paddles, broken machinery parts, or even damaged packaging lids,” he told Newsweek.
“While rare, it signals a lapse in manufacturing safeguards or supplier controls.”

He added that because this recall is Class II, it likely means either the contaminated products haven’t hit retail shelves yet—or that the plastic pieces are large enough to spot before eating.

What You Should Do

If you’re a distributor, food service provider, or operate a kitchen using bulk ice cream tubs:

• Check the lot numbers and UPC codes
• Immediately remove any affected products from circulation
• Follow disposal or return instructions per FDA guidelines

Consumers are unlikely to find these products in grocery store freezers, but businesses should act quickly to avoid any potential harm.

Full List of Recalled Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt Products

Here are all 22 affected products, including UPCs and lot numbers:

• Rocky Road Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050314, Lot 50009
• Mocha Almond Fudge Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050420, Lot 50016
• Peanut Butter ‘N Fudge Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050574, Lot 50012
• Country Rich Vanilla Ice Cream – UPC: 070640600052, Lot 50085
• Scooper Hero Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050642, Lot 50011
• Cotton Candy Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050482, Lot 50018
• GFGB Vanilla Bean Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640000272, Lot 50024
• Quick Blend Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050604, Lot 50034
• Planet Smoothie ZSA Vanilla Fat Free Frozen Yogurt – UPC: 070640005567, Lot 50014
• Johnny Rockets Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640006564, Lot 50029
• BIPC Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640008025, Lot 50024
• Vanilla Frozen Yogurt – UPC: 00070640022144, Lot 50002
• Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640022250, Lot 50005
• GFGB 12 Percent Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640018451, Lot 50004
• Gordon Choice Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 00093901820730, Lot 50003
• Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (Madagascar Vanilla) – UPC: 50758108658085, Lot 50026
• Glenview Farms Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 50758108118398, Lot 50066
• Glenview Farms Chocolate Ice Cream – UPC: 50758108118404, Lot 50033
• Glenview Farms French Vanilla Ice Cream – UPC: 50758108392668, Lot 50015
• Sysco French Vanilla Ice Cream – UPC: 00074865257275, Lot 50025
• Keith Valley Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 046045065871, Lot 50004
• Ellington Farms Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 046045065833, Lot 50003

Final Takeaway

While the chances of injury are slim, the recall is a smart, proactive move to protect public health. If you handle or distribute any of these products, check your stock now—and keep your customers safe.

For more updates on food safety recalls, follow our coverage or visit FDA.gov.

Source: Newsweek – Ice Cream Recalled Nationwide: Full List of Products Affected