Hamas Releases 8 Hostages, But Israel Halts Prisoner Swap Over Chaotic Handover

Hamas Releases 8 More Hostages Amid Chaotic Handover; Israel Delays Prisoner Swap

Tense Exchange Sparks Israeli Protest

Hamas released eight more hostages on Thursday as part of the ongoing ceasefire agreement in Gaza. However, the chaotic nature of the handover—where hostages were forced through a crowd of thousands by masked militants—angered Israel, prompting it to temporarily halt the planned release of 110 Palestinian prisoners.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu demanded assurances from mediators regarding the safety of future hostage transfers. Later, after receiving commitments from negotiators, Israeli media reported that the prisoner release would proceed as planned.

Hamas Uses Handover as Political Statement

In a dramatic move, Hamas released seven hostages in front of the destroyed home of its slain leader, Yahya Sinwar, in what the group called a “message of determination.” The event triggered diplomatic concerns, with U.S., Egyptian, and Qatari mediators scrambling to keep the fragile truce intact.

The first hostage freed was 20-year-old Israeli soldier Agam Berger. Hamas paraded her through the Jabaliya refugee camp in northern Gaza before handing her over.

Chaotic Handover in Khan Younis

The most intense scene unfolded hours later in Khan Younis, where Hamas and Islamic Jihad militants arrived in a convoy with the remaining seven hostages.

Thousands of people gathered, some climbing the ruins of bombed-out buildings to watch.

• Arbel Yehoud (29) appeared stunned and disoriented as masked militants pushed her through the shouting crowd.
• Gadi Moses (80), an Israeli man, was among those freed.
• Five Thai laborers were also released:
  • Watchara Sriaoun (33)
  • Pongsak Tanna (36)
  • Sathian Suwankam (35)
  • Bannawat Seathao (27)
  • Surasak Lamnau (32)

Thailand has been heavily impacted by Hamas’ October attack, with 23 Thai nationals among more than 100 hostages freed during a previous ceasefire in November 2023. Israel reports that three Thai hostages remain in captivity, with two believed to be dead.

Tensions Over Hostage Release Sequence

Arbel Yehoud was previously at the center of a dispute over the order in which hostages would be released. The United States, Egypt, and Qatar intervened, securing an agreement for her release on Thursday.

In Israel, about 20 of Yehoud’s friends watched the handover live. Some wept, while others covered their eyes or mouths in distress. The group erupted in tears of relief when she was finally turned over to the Red Cross.

Netanyahu Condemns ‘Shocking Scenes’

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu denounced the chaotic handover, calling for international mediators to ensure safe and orderly releases in the future.

Meanwhile, the ceasefire remains in place, but the next phase of negotiations will be even more difficult.

Ceasefire Terms & Uncertain Future

Under the current truce, Hamas has agreed to release 33 Israeli hostages, including women, children, the elderly, and wounded men, in exchange for nearly 2,000 Palestinian prisoners.

Israel has confirmed that eight of the hostages set to be released are dead.

One of the high-profile prisoners set for release is Zakaria Zubeidi, a former militant leader and theater director who gained notoriety after a dramatic 2021 prison break before being recaptured days later.

Palestinian Perspective on Prisoner Release

For many Palestinians, the release of prisoners is seen as a victory. Those detained are often viewed as heroes who have sacrificed in the fight against Israeli occupation.

Meanwhile, Israel has withdrawn most of its forces from Gaza, allowing hundreds of thousands of displaced residents to return to their devastated neighborhoods. Humanitarian aid efforts have increased, but conditions remain dire.

The next phase of negotiations could determine whether the ceasefire holds indefinitely or if war resumes in early March.

• Israel remains committed to destroying Hamas, even after the group quickly reasserted control over Gaza during the ceasefire.
• Far-right members of Netanyahu’s government are demanding a return to war once the first phase of hostage exchanges is completed.
• Hamas has declared that it will not release the remaining hostages unless Israel ends the war completely and fully withdraws from Gaza.

Human Cost of the War

The war, triggered by Hamas’ October 7, 2023 attack, has resulted in one of the deadliest conflicts in recent history:

• Hamas’ attack: 1,200 Israelis killed, mostly civilians, with 250 hostages taken.
• Israeli offensive: Over 47,000 Palestinians killed, more than half of whom were women and children, according to Gaza’s Health Ministry.
• Israeli military estimates: 17,000 Hamas fighters killed (though no evidence has been provided).

Entire neighborhoods in Gaza have been reduced to rubble. Around 90% of Gaza’s population has been displaced, with hundreds of thousands now living in overcrowded shelters or makeshift tents.

What Happens Next?

The coming weeks will determine whether the ceasefire evolves into a long-term peace deal or if hostilities resume. With both sides holding firm on their demands, the situation remains extremely fragile.

Will Hamas release the remaining hostages?
Will Israel continue military operations in Gaza?
Can international mediators secure a lasting truce?

The world is watching.

Source