Trump Criticizes FEMA and Suggests States Handle Disasters Directly

Trump Suggests Eliminating FEMA During Disaster Area Tour

President Donald Trump, while touring disaster-stricken areas in California and North Carolina on Friday, proposed a radical shift in disaster management: eliminating the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). Trump criticized the agency for being “bureaucratic” and “very slow,” suggesting states should take over disaster response efforts with direct funding from the federal government.

Trump’s Criticism of FEMA

“FEMA has been a very big disappointment,” Trump said during his visit to North Carolina, where communities are still recovering months after Hurricane Helene. He suggested letting states handle tornadoes, hurricanes, and other disasters directly, without relying on federal oversight.

This aligns with his broader vision of limiting federal government involvement, a stance supported by many conservative allies. Trump’s comments have drawn criticism from disaster response experts, including Michael Coen, a former FEMA chief of staff, who described the idea as “misinformed” and emphasized FEMA’s critical role in aiding overwhelmed states during catastrophes.

Tour of California Wildfire Zones

In California, Trump surveyed fire-ravaged areas, including Pacific Palisades, where entire neighborhoods were reduced to ashes. Accompanied by first lady Melania Trump, he walked through devastated streets, spoke with residents, and called the scene “devastation” and “incineration.”

Despite his rocky relationship with California’s Democratic leaders, Trump met with Governor Gavin Newsom, who called for federal support. “We’re going to need your help,” Newsom said, praising Trump’s cooperation during the COVID-19 pandemic and expressing optimism about future collaboration.

However, Trump’s tone toward California wasn’t entirely conciliatory. En route to Los Angeles, White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt referred to Newsom as “Newscum” and criticized him for “wronging the people of his state.” Trump also reiterated unfounded claims that California’s water policies worsened the fires.

Tensions Over Hazardous Waste

Trump also urged local officials to expedite rebuilding efforts by waiving permitting requirements, downplaying concerns about hazardous materials on burned properties. “What’s hazardous waste? We’re going to have to define that,” Trump said, dismissing the risks.

Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass emphasized the need to ensure residents’ safety from toxins before allowing them to return home, but her remarks were repeatedly interrupted by Trump, who pushed for faster action.

North Carolina: A Message of Support

In North Carolina, Trump visited towns still reeling from Hurricane Helene. Residents shared harrowing stories of fleeing waist-deep floodwaters and struggling with unresponsive insurance companies. Trump criticized the federal response under President Joe Biden, claiming residents were “treated very badly by the previous administration.”

“We’ve come to North Carolina with a simple message,” Trump told residents. “You are not forgotten any longer.”

Trump’s FEMA Replacement Plan

Trump proposed an alternative to FEMA’s current structure, suggesting federal disaster funds flow directly to states, bypassing FEMA altogether. Critics argue that such changes could leave states ill-equipped to handle large-scale disasters on their own. FEMA, as it stands, coordinates resources and provides financial aid when disasters overwhelm state capabilities, including debris removal and stopgap financial assistance for individuals.

Michael Whatley, chair of the Republican National Committee and a North Carolina native, was appointed by Trump to coordinate recovery efforts in the state, despite holding no official government role.

Climate Change Debate

Trump’s visits to North Carolina and California reignited debates about climate change, which he has consistently downplayed. Scientists have linked both Hurricane Helene and California’s wildfires to climate change.

• A study by World Weather Attribution found that climate change increased Helene’s rainfall by 10%.
• California’s record-dry winter left the state more vulnerable to fires, particularly in areas like Los Angeles.

Amanda Stasiewicz, a researcher at the University of Oregon, commented, “This is just breaking our comfort zone of what is supposed to be normal.”

Looking Ahead

Trump’s push to reshape disaster response raises questions about the federal government’s role in crises and the future of FEMA. His tour comes as he plans to hold a rally in Las Vegas on Saturday, shifting focus back to his political ambitions.

Source