Donald Trump’s rally at Madison Square Garden on Sunday night was meant to serve as a final push against Kamala Harris, but it quickly took an unexpected turn due to offensive remarks made from the stage. With just eight days left before the election, Trump and his campaign are now grappling with backlash over the inflammatory and racially charged language used during the event.
The comments in question, though intended as humor, were made by comedian Tony Hinchcliffe early in the night. His jokes, however, have shifted the spotlight onto Trump’s campaign for the wrong reasons, creating a wave of negative media attention in the final week before voting. Longtime Trump adviser Peter Navarro openly criticized Hinchcliffe, calling him “the biggest, stupidest asshole that ever came down the comedy pike” after he disparaged Puerto Rico as a “floating island of hot garbage.”
The remarks have fueled criticism from Trump’s opponents, who argue that the rally showcased divisive rhetoric. Former Trump aide Anthony Scaramucci likened the event to the infamous Nazi rally held in Madison Square Garden in 1939, stating, “What you saw last night is a divisive America. That’s race-baiting.” Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez labeled the event a “hate rally” on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe,” drawing parallels to other Trump rallies.
In response, several prominent Republicans also voiced their disapproval of the comedian’s remarks. Florida Senator Rick Scott, facing a reelection race in a state with a large Puerto Rican population, posted that the “joke bombed for a reason” and praised Puerto Ricans as “amazing Americans.” Representative María Elvira Salazar from Florida similarly condemned the remarks, noting, “This rhetoric does not reflect GOP values.”
The Harris campaign seized the opportunity, highlighting dozens of critical news headlines, TV clips, and social media posts denouncing the event. Puerto Rican celebrities, including Bad Bunny, Jennifer Lopez, and Ricky Martin, also expressed support for Harris in response to Hinchcliffe’s comments.
Hinchcliffe’s set included additional controversial jokes. He made a derogatory remark referencing “carving watermelons” after spotting a Black man in the audience. Another speaker, businessman Grant Cardone, likened Harris’s advisers to “pimp handlers.” Trump adviser Stephen Miller further added fuel to the fire by suggesting that American jobs are being “looted and stolen” by foreign interests, reinforcing an anti-immigration stance prevalent in Trump’s campaign.
Trump himself continued to use polarizing language, mocking critics who challenge his claim that political opponents represent America’s “enemy within.” He told the crowd, “When I say ‘the enemy from within,’ the other side goes crazy.”
The Trump campaign quickly distanced itself from Hinchcliffe’s performance. Campaign spokesperson Danielle Alvarez clarified, “This joke does not reflect the views of President Trump or the campaign.” While the campaign condemned the comedian’s comments, Trump has remained silent on the matter, aside from a post on Truth Social noting the event’s viewership.
Hinchcliffe defended himself on social media, arguing that his critics “have no sense of humor” and stating, “I love Puerto Rico and vacation there.” He asserted that his jokes were meant to poke fun at everyone and encouraged viewers to “watch the whole set.”
New Jersey congressional candidate Nellie Pou, a Puerto Rican, called the rally a stark reminder of Trump’s controversial response to Hurricane Maria in 2017, suggesting it revealed how he might treat Puerto Ricans if reelected.
