Amy Lynn Bradley’s Mysterious Disappearance: A Cruise Ship Vanishing That Still Haunts 26 Years Later

Netflix doc reignites interest in unsolved case of 23-year-old Virginia woman who vanished at sea

A Vacation That Turned Into a Nightmare

Amy Lynn Bradley, a 23-year-old from Virginia, vanished without a trace from a Royal Caribbean cruise ship on March 24, 1998, while sailing near Curaçao. Her unexplained disappearance—now the subject of Netflix’s new documentary Amy Lynn Bradley Is Missing—continues to baffle investigators and devastate her family nearly three decades later.

Amy had been traveling with her parents and younger brother aboard the Rhapsody of the Seas, a trip paid for by her father’s employer. After a night of dancing with fellow passengers and ship crew, Amy was last seen resting on the balcony of the family’s cabin around 5:30 a.m. Within 30 minutes, she was gone.

Last Known Movements

Amy and her brother Brad returned to their cabin in the early hours of March 24 after visiting the ship’s nightclub. Brad went to bed, and Amy stayed on the balcony. Their father, Ron, remembers seeing her asleep there shortly after 5 a.m. But by 6 a.m., she had vanished—leaving behind her shoes but reportedly taking her cigarettes and lighter.

Ron searched the ship before alerting his wife and ship personnel. The family pleaded with Royal Caribbean to delay passenger disembarkation in Curaçao, fearing Amy may have been taken off the vessel. Their request was denied, and passengers were allowed to leave as scheduled. The captain did not make an announcement about Amy’s disappearance until hours later.

Cruise Line Criticized for Handling

Despite a shipwide search and later efforts by Dutch investigators and Royal Caribbean, no definitive trace of Amy was ever found. The family later filed a lawsuit against the cruise line, accusing it of negligence and emotional distress. The case was dismissed in 2000.

Royal Caribbean maintained that it acted responsibly and assisted fully with the investigation. The company stated that the FBI conducted polygraph tests on certain crew members and found no evidence of wrongdoing.

A Promising Future Cut Short

Amy was a recent graduate of Longwood University in Virginia, where she studied physical education and played basketball. She had secured a job at a computer consulting firm and was planning to move into a new apartment and adopt an English bulldog shortly after the trip.

“She had so many plans. And she was so happy about all of them,” her mother, Iva, recalled.

Amy had several distinctive tattoos: a Tasmanian devil spinning a basketball on her shoulder, a sun on her lower back, a gecko on her navel, and a Chinese symbol on her ankle. Her belly button was also pierced—key details used in missing person flyers and tips submitted to authorities.

Encounters and Suspicious Details

While on the cruise, Amy was seen socializing with Alister “Yellow” Douglas, a member of the ship’s band. He later told investigators she was smoking heavily and seemed distressed, allegedly telling him her father had forced her on the cruise after finding out she was gay.

Douglas said they parted ways at 1 a.m., but conflicting accounts emerged. Some passengers claimed to have seen Amy with a musician from the band early that morning. Brad also remembered an uncomfortable exchange with Douglas hours later, when Douglas expressed regret—before the disappearance was public knowledge.

Ship staff and the FBI questioned Douglas, but no charges were filed.

Reported Sightings and Unconfirmed Leads

Over the years, multiple people have claimed to have seen Amy, particularly in the Caribbean. In April 1998, a cab driver in Curaçao said a woman matching Amy’s description frantically asked for a phone shortly after the ship docked.

Months later, a Canadian tourist reported seeing a woman on a beach who tried to approach him before being pulled away by two men. He was convinced it was Amy based on her tattoos and physical appearance.

In another incident, a U.S. Navy officer claimed a woman in a Curaçao brothel told him she was Amy Lynn Bradley and begged for help—but he didn’t act on the plea until later realizing who she was.

The Bradleys also received disturbing photos in 2005, showing a woman resembling Amy on an adult website based in the Caribbean. A forensic expert hired by the family concluded the woman was likely Amy, but the tip ultimately went cold.

Was Amy Trafficked?

Amy’s family and some investigators believe she may have been abducted and forced into human trafficking shortly after leaving the ship—or possibly even taken directly from the vessel. Her mother, Iva, has long insisted that Amy wouldn’t have voluntarily left or taken her own life.

“My intuition as a mother is somebody’s got her,” Iva said. “Somebody saw her, somebody wanted her and somebody took her.”

Investigation Continues—But Hope Fades

The FBI officially lists Amy Lynn Bradley as missing. Despite years of leads, none have provided conclusive answers. The case remains unsolved.

Netflix’s Amy Lynn Bradley Is Missing, released July 16, sheds new light on the investigation, the family’s heartbreak, and the lingering suspicion that Amy may still be alive somewhere, waiting to be found.