Israeli Government Dismisses Shin Bet Head Ronen Bar Amid Security Tensions

Netanyahu’s Government Votes to Dismiss Shin Bet Chief Ronen Bar

In a dramatic move, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government has voted to remove Ronen Bar as the head of Israel’s Shin Bet internal security service. The decision, made in the early hours of Friday local time, could still face legal challenges from Israel’s Supreme Court.

Official Statement and Timeline

The Prime Minister’s Office confirmed the unanimous vote, stating:
“The government has now unanimously approved Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s proposal to terminate the term of Shin Bet head Ronen Bar.”
Bar will officially step down on April 10, 2025, or when a permanent replacement is appointed, whichever comes first.

Netanyahu’s Justification for the Dismissal

Netanyahu met with Bar last week to inform him of his removal, citing a lack of trust in his leadership. In a video statement released Sunday, the Prime Minister explained his reasoning:

“At all times, but especially in such an existential war, the prime minister must have full confidence in the head of the Shin Bet.”
Netanyahu argued that Bar’s dismissal was crucial for achieving Israel’s military objectives in Gaza and for preventing future security threats.

The Prime Minister has repeatedly criticized Shin Bet’s handling of security, particularly in light of the October 7, 2023 Hamas attacks, which killed over 1,200 people. Netanyahu has accused Shin Bet leadership of failing to prevent the assault, though an internal agency report also pointed to government policies as contributing factors.

Political and Legal Challenges

Bar’s dismissal has sparked significant backlash from both legal experts and political figures:

• Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara informed Netanyahu that the government could not legally fire Bar without the approval of a special committee.
• Netanyahu dismissed this argument, accusing the attorney general of exceeding her authority and interfering in government affairs.
• Bar himself pushed back, stating that the vote was “hastily convened, contrary to every basic legal rule dealing with the right to be heard.”

Tensions Between Shin Bet and Netanyahu’s Government

The situation has been further complicated by ongoing tensions between Bar and Netanyahu’s administration.

• Shin Bet recently launched an investigation into allegations that members of Netanyahu’s office improperly lobbied on behalf of Qatar, a claim the Prime Minister’s Office denies.
• Netanyahu had already removed both Bar and Mossad chief David Barnea from Israel’s negotiation team for ceasefire and hostage talks with Hamas.

Opposition and Security Concerns

Critics argue that Bar’s removal is politically motivated and could harm Israel’s security.

• Opposition politicians warn that the move “sends a dangerous message” and could jeopardize critical intelligence operations.
• Bar, in his statement before the vote, emphasized that his removal could “directly endanger the security of the state of Israel.”

As the situation unfolds, all eyes remain on Israel’s Supreme Court, which may ultimately decide whether Bar’s dismissal will stand.