Misinformation Follows Charlie Kirk Assassination: Fact-Checking Viral Claims

Published Time: 09-18-2025, 14:30 EDT

The assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University has sparked a wave of misinformation and misleading narratives across social media platforms. Within hours of the shooting, false claims began circulating, misidentifying the suspect and misrepresenting events surrounding the case.

Authorities later confirmed 22-year-old Tyler Robinson as the suspect, arrested two days after the incident. However, before officials released verified details, online speculation fueled confusion and conspiracy theories. Here’s a breakdown of the most widely shared claims — and the verified facts.

Claim 1: The suspect was a registered Republican

The Facts: This is false. According to official Utah voting records, Tyler Robinson was registered as a voter but was not affiliated with any political party. His voter status is inactive, meaning he did not participate in two consecutive general elections after receiving notice from the county clerk.

Utah Gov. Spencer Cox stated that Robinson’s family reported he had become “more political in recent years” and had criticized Kirk publicly. Authorities also confirmed that ammunition recovered at the scene carried engravings with anti-fascist and meme-related messaging.

Claim 2: Robinson was a member of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA)

The Facts: This claim is untrue. Priscilla Yeverino, a spokesperson for the DSA, confirmed: “We have no members in DSA named Tyler Robinson anywhere in the country.”

The rumor appears to have originated from a photo of a person resembling Robinson wearing a DSA shirt with the slogan “bee the change.” Yeverino declined to verify that individual’s identity, citing concerns for privacy and safety. Despite the lack of evidence, some political figures and commentators speculated about Robinson’s political leanings, further spreading misinformation.

Claim 3: A video shows the shooter escaping after the incident

The Facts: This is misleading. The video circulating online was recorded on July 28 — more than a month before Kirk’s assassination. It actually depicts Dakota Hawver, the suspect in the Grand Sierra Resort shooting in Reno, Nevada.

In that case, Hawver killed three people and injured three others before being shot by police. He later died in the hospital. Despite the footage being widely available in news reports about the Reno tragedy, it was misrepresented online as evidence of Robinson fleeing the Utah scene.

Claim 4: Democrats opposed a moment of prayer for Charlie Kirk in the House

The Facts: This claim misrepresents what occurred. On Wednesday, Speaker Mike Johnson requested a moment of prayer for Kirk and his family. The House observed approximately 30 seconds of silence.

Afterward, Rep. Lauren Boebert called for a spoken prayer, prompting vocal objections and disorder on the House floor. Footage shows lawmakers debating, with some audible “no” responses to Boebert’s request. Speaker Johnson attempted to restore order, clarifying that prayer would follow the session. Social media clips omitting the initial silent prayer fueled claims that Democrats had outright opposed honoring Kirk.

Claim 5: The shooter was identified as Michael Mallinson or George Zinn

The Facts: Both identifications are false. Robinson was officially named as the suspect on Friday.

Canadian citizen Michael Mallinson, age 77, was misidentified online. He told CBC News that he realized the error only after his daughter called in distress, urging him to delete his social media accounts. Mallinson said he had “never heard of Charlie Kirk” before the shooting.

Another man, George Zinn, was briefly taken into custody after being filmed handcuffed by officers. The Utah Department of Public Safety later confirmed Zinn was detained but not charged in connection with Kirk’s death. He was instead charged with obstruction and has no current ties to the shooting.

The Pattern of Misinformation After Tragedy

Experts note that misinformation often spreads rapidly in the immediate aftermath of high-profile incidents. In this case, speculation about Robinson’s background, false videos, and misleading political narratives gained traction before official updates clarified the facts.

Authorities have urged the public to rely on verified statements from law enforcement and trusted news outlets. As investigations continue, officials caution against sharing unverified claims that could further fuel confusion or harm innocent individuals.

Conclusion

The assassination of Charlie Kirk has left a significant impact not only politically but also in highlighting how quickly misinformation can spread during national crises. While Tyler Robinson has been identified as the suspect, the incident underscores the importance of fact-checking and waiting for verified information before drawing conclusions.

Source: AP News – Assassination of Charlie Kirk prompts flood of false and misleading claims online