Disney’s Lilo & Stitch Trailer Reveals a Big Problem with Its Alien Characters

Disney’s Lilo & Stitch Trailer Reveals Too Many Live-Action Characters – And It’s a Problem

Disney has finally released the first full trailer for its live-action remake of Lilo & Stitch, and while fans were eager to see how the beloved alien characters would translate into the new format, some of the reveals have sparked controversy.

Not long ago, Polygon’s Petrana Radulovic urged Disney to showcase more than just Stitch in its promotional materials. Now that the trailer has dropped, the results are raising eyebrows—especially regarding Jumba and Pleakley.

One of the biggest appeals of the original animated film was its bold, cartoony alien designs. Fans were excited to see how Jumba, Pleakley, and Gantu would be reimagined in a photorealistic style. Instead, Disney took a different route—one that feels like a missed opportunity.

The new trailer reveals that instead of going full CGI or using prosthetics and animatronics, Jumba and Pleakley will be played by Zach Galifianakis and Billy Magnussen—and justified through hologram technology.

And to that, I say: Boring.

The charm of Jumba and Pleakley in the animated classic wasn’t just about their quirky personalities—it was about their weird, exaggerated appearances and how they attempted to “blend in” by wearing Hawaiian shirts and bucket hats.

This visual gag had a deeper subtext:

• The aliens weren’t just outsiders in their mannerisms and actions, but also in their physicality.
• Their disguises mirrored how tourists stand out when they visit unfamiliar cultures—an underlying theme in the original film.

By making them look too human with hologram tech, the film loses this layer of storytelling.

Disney has already proven it can bring non-human characters to life convincingly:

• They made two photorealistic Lion King movies without any human characters.
• Films like The Mandalorian have successfully blended practical effects, animatronics, and CGI for alien characters.

Jumba and Pleakley didn’t need to be fully CGI—they just needed to look alien in a way that remained visually and thematically consistent with the original film.

At the end of the day, Disney’s live-action remakes continue to dominate the box office, regardless of creative choices. And while Galifianakis and Magnussen are undoubtedly talented actors, they shouldn’t have to carry the weirdness of Jumba and Pleakley without proper visual support.

If we must have a live-action Lilo & Stitch, it deserves to be as weird and wonderful as the original—including its alien uncles.

Source